Friday, January 18, 2008

"Advertising is legalized lying."

-- H.G. Wells, quoted in Michael Jackman, Crown's Book of Political Quotations, 1982, New York: Crown Publishing Inc., p. 2.

From today's Washington Post:

Coal Industry Plugs Into the Campaign
By Steven Mufson
Washington Post Staff Writer
Friday, January 18, 2008; D01

A group backed by the coal industry and its utility allies is waging a $35 million campaign in primary and caucus states to rally public support for coal-fired electricity and to fuel opposition to legislation that Congress is crafting to slow climate change.

The group, called Americans for Balanced Energy Choices, has spent $1.3 million on billboard, newspaper, television and radio ads in Iowa, Nevada and South Carolina.

One of its television ads shows a power cord being plugged into a lump of coal, which it calls "an American resource that will help us with vital energy security" and "the fuel that powers our way of life." The ads note that half of U.S. electricity comes from coal-fired plants.

The group has also deployed teams on the campaign trail; about 50 people, many of them paid, walked around as human billboards and handed out leaflets outside Tuesday's Democratic debate in Nevada with questions for voters to ask the candidates.

"In Iowa, there is a saying that you don't get to be president unless you go through Iowa. We'd like to say that you don't get to be president unless you understand how complicated this issue is," Joe Lucas, the group's executive director, said Wednesday night during a stopover en route from Nevada to South Carolina.

The group's message -- that coal-fired power plants can be clean, and that more of them are needed to meet the growing demand for electricity -- comes when opposition to new coal plants is mounting because they generate greenhouse gases. In Kansas, where a state agency rejected a permit for two proposed coal plants, opinion polls show that roughly two out of three people opposed the plants. That sentiment, plus soaring construction costs and uncertainty about federal climate change legislation, last year prompted U.S. companies to abandon or postpone plans to build dozens of new coal plants.

The coal mining industry is fighting back. It increased the budget of the National Mining Association, the industry's main lobbying group, by 20 percent this year, to $19.7 million. Last September, the industry also boosted the budget of Americans for Balanced Energy Choices more than fourfold. The roster of backers includes 28 companies and trade associations such as Peabody Energy, Arch Coal, Duke Energy, Southern Co. and the National Rural Electric Cooperative Association.

The controversy over coal has been especially heated in Nevada, where environmental groups and Senate Majority Leader Harry M. Reid, who represents the state, have opposed construction of three new coal-fired power plants. "They're all dirty," Reid said last fall. He urged utilities to rely on energy efficiency and solar and wind power. (Last year, according to a report issued yesterday by the American Wind Energy Association, wind made up 30 percent of all new electricity generating capacity.)

On Tuesday night, the issue came up during the debate among the three leading Democratic presidential candidates.
Former senator John Edwards said, "I believe we need a moratorium on the building of any more coal-fired power plants unless and until we have the ability to capture and sequester the carbon in the ground."

Sen. Hillary Rodham Clinton (N.Y.) said, "I have said we should not be siting any more coal-powered plants unless they can have the most modern, clean technology. And I want big demonstration projects to figure out how we would capture and sequester carbon."

Sen. Barack Obama (Ill.) did not commit himself on coal plants but said Americans had to make their buildings, lighting and appliances "more efficient."

"Yes, we do need to be more energy efficient," Lucas said. "But even as we become more efficient, we're plugging more things into the wall."

The ads being run by Americans for Balanced Energy Choices talk about "clean coal." New power plants are cleaner than they used to be because they must meet more stringent federal regulations limiting such pollutants as nitrogen oxides and sulfur dioxide. But climate change is linked to carbon dioxide emissions, which are not yet regulated; those emissions have dropped more modestly as plants have become more efficient.

The group's newspaper ads avoid that distinction. They say that today's carbon-fired plants are "70 percent cleaner based on regulated emissions per unit of energy produced." That does not refer to carbon dioxide.

New coal-plant technologies that might capture carbon dioxide and store, or sequester, it underground are expensive, experimental and not in commercial use. But Lucas says carbon capture and storage "is no longer a pipe dream. It's nearing a point where it's real." Many environmentalists argue that until that time, the United States should focus on renewable energy such as solar and wind. Coal advocates say those energy sources cannot be relied on 24 hours a day and, so far, the energy they produce cannot be easily stored.

ABEC's ads, produced by the same firm that made "what happens here stays here" ads to promote Las Vegas to tourists, also talk about "affordable" energy. The group says in a TV ad that the price of coal is one-third that of other fuels. But coal prices have risen, albeit not as much as oil. And environmentalists and economists argue that the price of coal does not include substantial environmental costs.

"We welcome a vigorous debate about our energy future and solving global warming. Unfortunately ABEC is spending millions of dollars on misinformation about our energy choices . . . instead of engaging in a real debate about the true costs of coal and clean energy alternatives," said Bruce Nilles, director of Sierra Club's national coal campaign.

Environmentalists are also worried that the ads aired by ABEC so far are just the beginning of what could be a much bigger offensive once Congress gets down to work on a climate change bill sponsored by Sens. Joseph I. Lieberman (I-Conn.) and John W. Warner (R-Va.). An ad targeting that bill is currently being shown on video monitors at the baggage carousels at Dulles International Airport.

In 1993, an ad campaign by the health-care industry featuring a fictional couple named Harry and Louise helped torpedo the Clinton administration's health-care proposal. Now, some supporters of the Lieberman-Warner bill fear that the coal industry may use a similar strategy to kill legislation aimed at slowing climate change by stressing potential consumer costs and not the societal benefits.

"Big coal may launch a 'Harry and Louise'-style disinformation campaign to sink global warming solutions in Congress," said Daniel J. Weiss, senior fellow and director of climate strategy for the Center for American Progress.

One of the coal industry group's radio ads hints at those themes. A woman asks: "How can we become less dependent on foreign resources? What fuels will keep power bills reasonable and be environmentally responsible?" A man responds, "We have many questions for our candidates, and coal has to be part of the discussion."

Lucas is working on that. Last year, he wrote letters that appeared in a dozen newspapers. On Tuesday, he appeared on Nevada public radio. On Wednesday, the group's views were quoted approvingly in an editorial in the Las Vegas Review-Journal. "We're getting the message out," Lucas said.

38 comments:

Anonymous said...

"Advertising is legalized lying."

-- H.G. Wells

This Blog = Advertising for Enviros

Anonymous said...

http://truffulaseed.ccpblogs.com/2008/01/17/early-applications-being-accepted-at-santee-coopers-coal-fired-energy-campus/

Student said...

Funny Anonymous, I thought this post linked to a Washington Post article -- but I guess amoral coal-boosters like you think that is advertising (Washington Post = enviro rag, right?). I was amused by a previous post of your in which you took the position that facts are "boring." If thats the case, why don't you just crawl back into your spider hole? You're a dinosaur.

Anonymous said...

Student, don't be ridiculous. In general, this site is like a street preacher talking trash to a missionary.

It was very obvious in the post you refer to that anonymous was merely mocking the silly, overheated rhetoric this site uses to respond to facts - most of which are admittedly imperfect, but not nearly as bad and certainly not as sinister as your warped view of reality seems to demand. Generally these facts seem to indicate environmental improvement. The improvement might not be as fast as we'd like, but I find it shocking that many would prefer stagnation to technological advances. I think it's sad and bizarre that idealogy blinds many to real improvements taking place out there, and thus inhibits pragmatic solutions that improve our world.

Those who criticize, loudly, from the outside seem to take an inordinate amount of pride in the noise they make, while those working on the inside - in academia, in government, in industry - make real environmental improvements. I suppose all engines must generate some noise or waste heat, though...why should the environmental engine be any different?

Anonymous said...

Speaking of improvement, I really like the polar bear holding up the sign "No New Coal" in the above post.

On the back it should say "So we can run the older, less efficient coal plants even harder!!!"

Anonymous said...

Thanks Anon, for pointing that out. I think all these folks whose main focus is simply "protesting" (holding up "No More XXX" signs, beating a drum, etc.) should sit back, away from the noise, and think for just a moment.

Their best outcome, is par. Let's say they stop X. Usually it is replaced by Y, or worse yet, X-1.

If they could only take that same enthusiasm and funnel it into working for a business (heaven forbid) or academia working to improve the environment, think of what we could accomplish!

Public Service Chump said...

...or maybe they could get a job with a bloated, antiquated, government-sanctioned monopoly (i.e. socialist institution), and ignore said protesters' calls for 1% annual energy efficiency gains, which would put money back in folks' pockets and make a new coal plant unnecessary.

Or is Santee Cooper not hiring now?

Anonymous said...

Hello
Companies House Webcheck
Webcheck Companies House
Company House Webcheck
Companies House Webcheck Service

[url=http://perosnalbinking.v3host.be/companies-house-webcheck.html]companies house webcheck[/url]

Anonymous said...

[url=http://www.facebook.com/pages/weathercom/298713874092l]www.weather.com[/url]

first time young sex stories said...

I then have her clean my dick off with her mouth whichshe has never done. I began to respondtouching him in kind.
bdsm cafe stories
true blackmailed sex stories
sexy wives stories
free stories of beastiality
drunk porn stories
I then have her clean my dick off with her mouth whichshe has never done. I began to respondtouching him in kind.

Anonymous said...

diazepam 10mg diazepam 5 mg high dosage - diazepam 2 mg side effects

Anonymous said...

order xanax buy-xanaxonline.com - xanax side effects recreational

Anonymous said...

diazepam half life buy diazepam nz - buy diazepam online no rx

Anonymous said...

buy ambien ambien side effects migraine - ambien 10mg

Anonymous said...

diazepam online buy diazepam usa 10mg - diazepam valium mechanism action

Anonymous said...

buy zolpidem zolpidem er generic ambien cr - dosage zolpidem tartrate dose

Anonymous said...

purchase xanax xanax zyprexa - xanax drug alternative

Anonymous said...

ativan cost symptoms of ativan overdose - ativan knocks me out

Anonymous said...

xanax online how does xanax and alcohol kill you - xanax for anxiety side effects

Anonymous said...

buy ambien online overnight delivery generic ambien cr fda - ambien side effects long term use

Anonymous said...

buy ambien online ambien high grasscity - generic ambien cr good

Anonymous said...

buy soma buy somatomax australia - buy soma online usa

Anonymous said...

buy valium online can you buy valium over the counter in spain - street prices of valium

Anonymous said...

buy ambien no prescription buy ambien online fast shipping - ambien cr trial offer

Anonymous said...

soma for sale carisoprodol 749 - carisoprodol overdose mg

Anonymous said...

valium sale mexican pharmacy valium - order valium online mastercard

Anonymous said...

order ambien online no prescription where to buy ambien in canada - take 2 ambien cr 12.5

Anonymous said...

can you buy valium online side effects valium empty stomach - generic valium pill identifier

Anonymous said...

buy valium online valium no prescription - valium no prescription australia

Anonymous said...

Blogger: CleanEnergySC.com - Post a Comment order prednisolone - purchase prednisone http://www.ourdailybreadmarket.net/#purchase-prednisone

Anonymous said...

Hi, MoxoredapeTox meridia cost - where to buy meridia diet pills http://www.amaryllisgarden.com/#where-to-buy-meridia-diet-pills

Anonymous said...

Drug Metabolism Post Liver Resection buy prednisolone online - buy cheap prednisone http://www.prednisone4sale.com/#buy-cheap-prednisone

Anonymous said...

Hello, lipitor price - lipitor cost http://www.costoflipitoronline.net/#lipitor-cost

Anonymous said...

Cost Of Hair Analysis Drugs order topamax no prescription - buy topiramate http://www.topamaxbetterprice.com/

Anonymous said...

Maio List Of Drugs buy fluconazole - buy diflucan no prescription http://www.diflucansaleonline.net/#buy-diflucan-no-prescription , [url=http://www.diflucansaleonline.net/#order-diflucan-online ]order diflucan online [/url]

Anonymous said...

Kidney Failure Drugs buy generic lexapro - buy lexapro http://www.costoflexaproonline.net/#buy-lexapro , [url=http://www.costoflexaproonline.net/#buy-lexapro-online ]buy lexapro online [/url]

Anonymous said...

tfv clomid cost - clomid price http://www.clomidonlinediscount.net/#buy-clomiphene, [url=http://www.clomidonlinediscount.net/#buy-clomiphene]clomid online no prescription [/url]

Anonymous said...

1 cymbalta for sale - buy cymbalta online http://www.cymbaltabuyonline.net/#order-cymbalta-online, [url=http://www.cymbaltabuyonline.net/#order-cymbalta-online]generic cymbalta[/url]